On this page
- TL;DR
- Table of Contents
- Why vetting a playlist matters more than landing one
- The 15-minute check, step by step
- A quick scoring system
- Red flags in the pitch or the offer
- What happens if your track lands on a botted playlist
- If you already landed on a suspicious playlist
- Where to find playlists that pass the test
- Our view: relationships beat one-off placements
- Pitch real curators with Playlist Pilot
- Sources
A legit Spotify playlist has real people listening to it, a curator you can identify, and growth that looks gradual rather than bought. You can check all three in about 15 minutes with free data: the playlist's follower pattern, the curator's profile, and the "Discovered On" section of artists already on it. If two or three checks fail, skip the playlist. A fake placement can cost you money and put your track at risk, as explained below. For a fast first pass, run the playlist through our free playlist bot checker.
TL;DR
- Follower count alone proves nothing. Look at who the curator is, how the playlist grew, and whether real listeners show up in artists' stats.
- Spikes and drops, streams from places that make no sense, and a handful of tracks with tiny stream counts on a "huge" playlist are the classic bot signals.
- Any service that guarantees playlist placement for money breaks Spotify's terms, so a guarantee in a pitch is a reason to walk away.
- Tracks tied to artificial streams can lose royalties or be taken down, so vet playlists before you pitch, not after.
- If you already landed on a suspicious playlist, document it, tell Spotify and your distributor, and stop promoting that placement.
Table of Contents
- Why vetting a playlist matters more than landing one
- The 15-minute check, step by step
- A quick scoring system
- Red flags in the pitch or the offer
- What happens if your track lands on a botted playlist
- If you already landed on a suspicious playlist
- Where to find playlists that pass the test
- Our view: relationships beat one-off placements
- Pitch real curators with Playlist Pilot
- FAQ
- Sources
Why vetting a playlist matters more than landing one
Most artists treat a placement as a win. On a botted playlist it is a liability. Spotify defines an artificial stream as one that does not reflect genuine listening intent, including attempts to manipulate the service with bots or scripts, and it says undetected artificial streams take money from the royalty pool that legitimate artists would otherwise earn.
The consequences land on you, not the playlist owner. Since April 2024, Spotify has charged labels and distributors per track when flagrant artificial streaming is detected. Your distributor's policy shows how that is passed on: FUGA states that Spotify charges €10 per track per month when artificial streaming is detected at scale, and that distributors pass deductions on to clients. Another distributor help page warns that a service which finds boosted play counts may remove an entire catalog without paying for those plays.
That is why a few minutes of checking before you pitch is the cheapest promotion work you will do all year.
The 15-minute check, step by step
Work through these in order. Each step takes a couple of minutes, and each one eliminates a different kind of fake.
Step 1: Look at the curator, not just the playlist
Spotify does not publicly show a playlist's own follower breakdown, but it does show who follows the curator. LANDR's guide says accounts with no photo, keyboard-mashed usernames and almost no activity are a warning sign, and that is easy to see by opening the curator's follower list.
Ask these questions:
- Does the curator have a real name, photo or any trace of a human behind the account?
- Do the curator's followers look like people, or like a list of random strings?
- Does a curator with a few dozen followers somehow run a playlist with tens of thousands?
- Does every playlist they own have roughly the same save count?
CD Baby lists inauthentic photos, nonsense usernames and near-identical save counts across a curator's playlists as signs of a curator profile that is not real. Real curators usually have a taste, a story, and playlists with different audiences.
Step 2: Read the playlist itself
A real curator has a point of view. Open the playlist and look for:
- A coherent sound. A playlist that jumps from lo-fi beats to metal to Latin pop has no curatorial vision.
- A real description. Robotic or keyword-stuffed text is a flag.
- Branding that imitates Spotify. CD Baby notes that user playlists sometimes copy Spotify's editorial look, with the logo in the top left, Spotify-style fonts and lifestyle imagery, to look official.
- A believable track mix. Symphonic's help page points to playlists where mostly unknown artists sit under a large following, and where the same artists dominate several playlists from one curator.
Generic names like "Chill Vibes 2026" are not proof of a fake by themselves, but combined with an anonymous curator they matter.
Step 3: Compare followers with real listening
Follower count is the only public number Spotify shows for a playlist, and followers do not necessarily listen. So test the number against what the tracks are doing. If the playlist claims 50,000 followers but the songs on it have only a few thousand total streams each, the audience probably is not real. That ratio logic is common across industry checklists, and the useful version is to look at the stream counts on the tracks in the playlist and ask whether they fit the audience being claimed.
Two more signals help here:
- Growth shape. If you can see follower history in a tool, slow regular growth looks natural. Sudden spikes followed by drops often mean followers were bought, removed and bought again.
- Artists you know. If an artist's tracks sit on the playlist, check whether it shows up in their stats. That leads to the next step.
Step 4: Check "Discovered On"
This is the strongest free test. Find an artist on the playlist, open their Spotify profile on desktop, and look at the playlists listed under "Discovered On", which show the playlists that sent them listeners in the last 28 days. A playlist with tens of thousands of followers that never shows up for any artist on it is not driving real discovery.
You can also do the reverse with your own music. Once you have a placement, open Spotify for Artists and see whether the playlist appears as a real source of listeners. If a playlist claims to be sending you traffic but your numbers do not move, the traffic is not real.
Step 5: Read your own Spotify for Artists data for abnormal activity
Spotify's guidance lists what abnormal activity looks like in your data: a sudden spike in streams with no apparent reason followed by a drop-off, an unexplained spike from a location where the track has not been active before, most streams coming from surprising sources such as "Other", and short-lived follower surges.
CD Baby adds two practical checks: watch for streams-per-listener ratios well above the typical 3 to 5 times per listener, and be wary of low-population areas with disproportionately high streaming. If any of these appear soon after a new placement, treat the playlist as the prime suspect.
Step 6: Run a bot scan, then judge the result with your own eyes
A scanner saves time on the mechanical part: follower patterns, curator signals, listener-to-follower relationships. Our free Spotify playlist bot checker is built for this, and you can use it on any playlist before you spend a minute drafting a pitch. A scan is a fast filter. Pair it with steps 1 to 4, because a tool score cannot tell you whether the curator answers messages or whether artists like you ever got real listeners from the list.
A quick scoring system
Use this table as a rule of thumb. It is a decision aid for your own vetting, not a guarantee.
| Check | Healthy sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Curator profile | Real name or photo, varied playlists, real-looking followers | No photo, gibberish username, near-identical save counts |
| Playlist identity | Clear genre, mood or scene, written description | Random genre mix, robotic text, mimics Spotify branding |
| Followers vs. streams | Track streams fit the audience size | Large following but tiny stream counts |
| Discovered On | Playlist appears in stats of artists on it | Never appears for anyone |
| Growth | Steady and gradual | Spikes and drops |
| Track mix | Mix of known and emerging artists | Only tiny artists, same names across a curator's lists |
Three or more warning signs: skip it. One warning sign on its own: look closer before deciding.
Red flags in the pitch or the offer
Sometimes the playlist looks fine and the offer is the problem. Spotify's US support page states that any service guaranteeing playlist placement in exchange for money violates its terms and conditions. So a guarantee is not a selling point, it is a warning.
CD Baby's list of pitch red flags is a useful screen:
- Guaranteed streams or virality for a fee
- No contactable human
- No clear explanation of how promotion works
- Unrealistic promises
- Unsolicited outreach out of nowhere
- Fees to keep your music on a playlist
- No reviews or artists who can vouch for the service
If a curator messages you first, verify before you reply. Steel Country's guidance on playlist promotion scams says not to use the link, phone number or email inside the message. Instead, open the Spotify app yourself, search the playlist by name, and confirm the owner matches the sender. Then contact a couple of artists on the list through their own channels and ask whether the placement did anything.
For a deeper walk-through of scam patterns, see our guide to spotting Spotify playlist scams.
What happens if your track lands on a botted playlist
The risk is real but manageable if you move quickly. The pieces that matter:
- Royalties. Artificial streams can show up in sales reports with earnings type "Artificial Streams" and $0.00, according to Soundrop's support page, which also says an artificial streaming penalty can be charged to the distributor and passed on to the artist.
- The 1,000-stream rule. Spotify's 2024 policy requires a track to reach at least 1,000 streams in the previous 12 months, plus an undisclosed minimum number of unique listeners, to enter the royalty pool. Fake streams do not help you here, because they are the ones that get flagged.
- Your catalog. Repeated manipulation can put more than one track at risk.
FUGA's advice is that if an investigation confirms artificial streaming from illegitimate marketing or playlisting, the track should be removed from all stores, because leaving it live may bring recurring penalties if the streaming persists.
If you already landed on a suspicious playlist
Do these in order:
- Screenshot everything. Save the playlist page, the curator profile, and any messages or receipts.
- Check your stats. Look at Spotify for Artists for the abnormal patterns listed in step 5.
- Tell Spotify. Spotify's support page says artists can notify it directly about suspicious playlists their music has been added to, and Spotify investigates before acting.
- Contact your distributor. They receive monthly reports on flagged tracks and can explain your options. Our guide to triaging fake Spotify streams covers what to say.
- If you paid, call your payment provider quickly. Steel Country notes recovery is not guaranteed, so speed matters.
- Stop sharing the placement. Do not promote it, and ask the curator to remove the track if you can reach a real person.
Where to find playlists that pass the test
Checking is half the job. The other half is a pipeline of curators who are real people and who will answer you. Manual searching is the slow part: finding the curator, checking the profile, finding contact details, writing a pitch that shows how your song fits.
That is the work we built Playlist Pilot to shorten. The platform matches your track to playlists run by real human curators by analyzing its audio characteristics, genre and mood, and it generates a personalized pitch showing why the song fits. It also runs a bot-detection system to verify curator authenticity, so the playlists you pitch have already been screened. If you want to see how the pitching side works, start with our guide to submitting to Spotify playlists, and for the etiquette, see how to pitch curators through open submissions.
Once your playlist plan is clean, the release itself needs its own plan. Our partners' notes on how to promote a new single cover what to do before, on and after release day, which pairs well with a vetted playlist list.
Our view: relationships beat one-off placements
We think the real danger on Spotify is not only bots. It is the pay-per-placement model that makes artists chase a number instead of an audience. When you pay for a one-off placement, you get one result and no relationship. When you build direct contact with a real curator, you get a person who knows your sound and who you can send your next song to. That is why Playlist Pilot does not charge per pitch: artists keep direct contact with curators for future submissions. Our pitches are generated with AI so that each one shows the curator how a song fits their playlist, and curators respond to that. The average response rate from curators is 47%. Combined with a bot-detection check on every curator, the goal is simple: fewer wasted pitches, no risky placements, and a list of curators who actually know your name. Vet every playlist, and keep the ones that vet you back. Zander
Pitch real curators with Playlist Pilot
Playlist Pilot offers a Starter plan at $19.99 per month and a Professional plan at $29.99 per month, with an Enterprise plan available too. There is no per-pitch charge, so you can keep contacting the curators you have built a relationship with. Plans and details are on the Playlist Pilot site.
If you only need a quick check first, the playlist checker is free to use.
Sources
- Artificial Streaming, Spotify for Artists
- Artificial streaming and paid third-party services that guarantee streams, Spotify Support (US)
- Changes to Spotify's royalty model, Music Business Worldwide
- Understanding Spotify's Artificial Streaming Penalty, FUGA
- Streaming Services: PR Fraud and Scams, Proton Help Center
- Spotify monetization eligibility and sales reports, Soundrop
- Is My Music in a Bot Playlist?, LANDR
- 5 tips to avoid fake Spotify playlists and streams, CD Baby
- Best Practices for Streaming Safely, Symphonic
- A Playlist Curator Wants Money: Verify the Identity, Steel Country
Ready to Get Real Playlist Placements?
Join Playlist Pilot and connect with curators who'll actually listen to your music.
