guide

Editorial vs Algorithmic Playlists on Spotify: Which to Pitch

Editorial playlists are picked by Spotify staff, algorithmic ones by listener data. Learn how each works, what each can do for your streams and how to pitch both.

Playlist Pilot
On this page
  1. TL;DR
  2. Table of Contents
  3. The difference in one table
  4. How editorial playlists work
  5. How algorithmic playlists work
  6. The hybrid in the middle: "algotorial" playlists
  7. Which one should you pitch first?
  8. The third lane: playlists run by independent curators
  9. Where Playlist Pilot fits
  10. A release plan that uses all three
  11. Common mistakes
  12. Perspective
  13. Sources

Editorial playlists are chosen by people on Spotify's staff. Algorithmic playlists are built for each listener by software, using that listener's habits. You pitch the first through one form in Spotify for Artists. You earn the second through how real listeners react to your song. The most reliable way to feed both is to put the song in front of listeners who already want it, and human-curated playlists are where independent artists can do that on their own schedule.

That is the whole map. The rest of this article shows how each type works, what each can realistically do for your streams and how to build a release plan that uses all of them.

TL;DR

  • Editorial playlists (Today's Top Hits, RapCaviar, Pollen) are curated by Spotify editors. You can pitch one unreleased song at a time through Spotify for Artists, but you cannot pay for placement.
  • Algorithmic playlists (Discover Weekly, Release Radar, Daily Mix) are generated per listener from listening behavior. You cannot submit to them, but you can influence them.
  • Most real playlists are hybrids. Editors choose a pool of songs and algorithms pick and order tracks for each listener.
  • Listener signals connect the two. Saves, full listens and repeat plays from real people are what move a song from one playlist type to the next.
  • Independent playlists run by human curators are the third lane you control directly, and the best way to generate those early signals.

Table of Contents

The difference in one table

EditorialAlgorithmic ("Made for You")
Who decidesSpotify's in-house editorsSoftware, using each listener's taste profile
ExamplesToday's Top Hits, RapCaviar, PollenDiscover Weekly, Release Radar, Daily Mix
Same list for everyone?Often yes (some are personalized)No, every listener gets a different list
How you get inPitch an unreleased song in Spotify for ArtistsRelease music, build listener signals, pitch for Release Radar timing
Can you pay for it?NoNo
Update rhythmSet by editorsWeekly for the main ones

Spotify's own guide to playlist types draws the same line: editors are genre, lifestyle and culture specialists, while personalized playlists are built by algorithms from what and when someone listens, what they add to playlists and what similar listeners do.

How editorial playlists work

Editorial playlists are made by Spotify employees who follow a genre, a region or a mood full time. They are the playlists most artists picture when they say "getting playlisted by Spotify." Spotify groups them under the label Made by Editors, with Today's Top Hits and Pollen as examples, in its overview of how playlists help songs reach fans.

Two details matter for an independent artist.

Editorial placement is a ladder, not a lottery. Spotify describes a "Playlist Pyramid." Songs typically start on local or regional playlists streamed by highly engaged fans, move up to larger regional lists if they perform, may be tested in other markets and only then reach global playlists. Today's Top Hits sits at the top, reserved for globally resonant songs. The same source says placements combine editorial expertise with data, so a song that holds attention at the bottom rung has a reason to climb.

Follower counts are not the entry ticket. In a Q&A with its playlist editors, Spotify said that followers and monthly listeners do not factor into editors' placement decisions. It also reported that, since launching pitching in 2018, it had playlisted 72,000 artists and about 20% of pitches as of February 2020. That figure is old, so treat it as a sense of scale rather than a current success rate. Both points come from Spotify's editor Q&A.

What an editorial placement is worth

The biggest slots are very large. An NBER study of Spotify's playlists found that Today's Top Hits, which had 18.5 million followers during the sample period, raised a song's streams by almost 20 million. A number one ranking on U.S. New Music Friday added about 14 million. The authors also found that New Music Friday inclusion substantially raised the odds of success for new artists, and that these lists had larger shares of domestic and independent-label music than global lists. Details are in the Aguiar and Waldfogel paper.

Read those numbers as a ceiling, not an expectation. The study covers 2016 to 2017, and the top slots take a tiny share of all submissions. What holds up is the pattern: editorial playlists can change a career-sized number of streams in a week, which is why they are worth a proper pitch.

How algorithmic playlists work

Algorithmic playlists, which Spotify calls Made for You, are not one list. They are millions of lists, one per listener. Discover Weekly, Release Radar and Daily Mix show different songs to different people because each is assembled from that person's own taste profile.

Spotify's recommendations explainer says searching, listening, skipping and saving to Your Library all shape a listener's taste profile. The systems also look at the content itself, such as genre and release date.

For you, that translates into a short list of behaviors to earn:

  • Saves and playlist adds, which tell the system a listener wants the song again.
  • Full listens, because a song skipped in the first seconds is a weak signal.
  • Follows, which matter most for Release Radar, since it draws on artists a listener follows.
  • Matching the right audience, because a song pushed to listeners who do not like the genre generates skips, not saves.

The last point is the one independent artists get wrong most often. Algorithmic playlists reward fit. A thousand listeners who genuinely like your sound do more for you than ten thousand who do not.

Release Radar: the one you can plan around

Release Radar is the algorithmic playlist with a clear action attached. According to Spotify's Release Radar guidance, it updates every Friday with new releases from artists a listener follows, artists they listen to and others Spotify thinks they will like. A song stays eligible for up to four weeks, and each listener gets one song per artist per week. If you pitch at least seven days before release, you can choose which song appears.

Discover Weekly works differently. It is taste-based, refreshes weekly and has no submission form. Spotify's editors have said there is nothing specific an artist can do to get onto this kind of playlist, so your lever is the listener behavior above. For a plain-language walkthrough, see our guide to how Discover Weekly works.

The hybrid in the middle: "algotorial" playlists

Search results for this topic often mention "algotorial," and it matters because the clean split above is not how many playlists work. Spotify defines algotorial as editors curating a pool of tracks that algorithms then personalize for each listener, as described in its newsroom post on personalized recommendations.

Spotify Engineering explains the process in a post on algotorial playlists. Editors define a listener need, such as a road trip, write a hypothesis about what fits it and build a pool of tracks. Algorithms then select and order tracks for each person. In that post, RapCaviar is described as fully editorial, while Discover Weekly, Daily Mix and Your Time Capsule are powered by personalization algorithms.

What this means in practice:

  1. Your editorial pitch can reach algorithmic surfaces. A pitch is read by a person, but a placement in a pool still depends on listeners reacting well.
  2. Your listener data can reach editors. Editors work with data insights, so a song that is already holding attention has a stronger case.
  3. You cannot sort every playlist into one box. Treat the table above as a guide, not a law.

Which one should you pitch first?

You do not choose between them. You sequence them around a release.

Before release: pitch the editors

The editorial pitch is free and has a hard deadline. Per Spotify's pitching instructions:

  1. Log in to Spotify for Artists and go to Music, then Upcoming.
  2. Choose the song and complete the pitch form.
  3. Deliver the music at least seven days before release.
  4. Pitch one song at a time. Compilations and songs you are only featured on cannot be pitched.
  5. Edit the pitch any time until release day.

Pitching at least seven days out also adds the song to your followers' Release Radar. Pitching does not guarantee placement, so plan as if it will not land and let it be a bonus. Spotify is also explicit that artists cannot pay for placement on its official playlists, and that offers to do so are streaming manipulation services that go against its guidelines, as stated in the same newsroom guide. Anyone selling you an editorial slot is selling you a risk to your account.

On release day and after: build real listening

This is where algorithmic playlists are decided. Spotify's own figure is that 33% of new artist discoveries happen in personalized sessions such as Discover Weekly, Radio, Autoplay and Mixes, according to its Made to Be Found announcement. The same post says more than 150,000 artists were playlisted for the first time across 2020 and 2021 through editorial curation. Both doors are open to new names, and neither one is open to a song nobody is listening to.

A sensible release-week routine:

  • Send the song to your existing followers and ask for saves, not just plays.
  • Pitch human-curated playlists that fit the song's genre and mood, so early listeners are the right listeners.
  • Track saves and skips in Spotify for Artists and adjust who you target next.

Our guide to getting on Release Radar and Discover Weekly covers the sequence in more detail.

The third lane: playlists run by independent curators

Spotify's own three categories include Made by You, the playlists created by listeners and independent curators. This is the lane that does not wait for a form to be reviewed. A real person with a real audience can add your song within days, and each listener they send you is a potential save, follow or replay. Those are exactly the signals that algorithmic playlists read. We break the category down in our overview of curated playlist types.

The catch is workload. Finding fitting curators, writing a message each one will actually read and keeping track of replies can eat a week of your release schedule. That is the part of the job a tool should do for you.

If you want the principles first, our pieces on curator outreach and how to network with music curators explain what curators respond to.

Where Playlist Pilot fits

Playlist Pilot is an AI-powered platform for independent musicians. It analyzes the audio characteristics, genre and mood of your track and matches it with playlists run by real human curators. It then generates a personalized pitch that shows each curator how your song fits their playlist, so you are not hand-writing every message. Our explanation of how AI matches songs to playlists walks through that process.

Two things make this useful for the editorial-versus-algorithmic question. First, fit is what algorithmic playlists reward, and matching by sound and mood puts your song in front of listeners likely to save it. Second, we do not charge per pitch, so you keep direct contact with the curators you reach and can go back to them with your next release. Curators have responded to an average of 47% of pitches sent through the platform.

Plans are published on the Playlist Pilot pricing page: Starter is $19.99 per month and Professional is $29.99 per month. Enterprise is also available, with no published price. If you are ready to send your first round, start with the Spotify submission page.

For a cost comparison between per-pitch and subscription models, our per pitch versus subscription breakdown uses Spotify's rules as the yardstick.

A release plan that uses all three

Here is how the pieces fit on a single single release.

Three to four weeks before release. Finish the pitch in Spotify for Artists: genre, mood, instruments, story. Write it for an editor who has a few minutes per song. Use the same story to prepare your curator message.

At least seven days before release. Submit the editorial pitch and confirm the song you want on Release Radar. This is the one deadline Spotify enforces.

Release week. Start curator outreach to matched human-run playlists and ask your existing audience for saves. Early placements and saves feed the signals that personalization reads.

Weeks two to four. Your song remains eligible for Release Radar for up to four weeks. Keep adding curator placements, then check which ones brought saves and repeat listens, not just plays.

Next release. Go back to the curators who added you. Because the relationship is direct, the next pitch starts from a warmer position.

The broader point is that editors, algorithms and curators are not rivals. A placement in one creates the audience behavior the others look for.

Common mistakes

  • Pitching late. Miss the seven-day window and you lose the editorial pitch and the chance to choose your Release Radar track.
  • Buying placements. Official playlists cannot be bought, and paid-placement offers go against Spotify's guidelines.
  • Chasing plays over saves. Skips are a negative signal. Aim for listeners who finish the song and come back.
  • Pitching the wrong genre. A mismatched playlist generates skips, which can hurt the profile the algorithm builds for your track.
  • Treating one placement as the finish line. An editorial slot rotates off. What carries a song after that is how listeners behaved while it was there.

Perspective

We see editorial and algorithmic playlists as two halves of the same discovery system, and independent artists tend to spend their energy on the half they control least. You cannot lobby an algorithm, and you cannot make an editor listen sooner. What you can do is put your song in front of people who are likely to love it, in numbers that add up to real saves. That is why we built Playlist Pilot around fit: audio, genre and mood matched to playlists run by real curators, with a pitch that explains the match. We also think the relationship matters more than the single placement. A tool that charges for every pitch quietly discourages you from going back to the people who liked your last song. We do not charge per pitch, so a curator who added you once is a contact you keep for the next release and the one after it. Pitch Spotify's editors every time, because it costs nothing and the upside is large. Then build the audience behavior that makes both editors and algorithms take notice. Zander

Sources

Ready to Get Real Playlist Placements?

Join Playlist Pilot and connect with curators who'll actually listen to your music.

Start Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Discover Weekly editorial or algorithmic?
Discover Weekly is algorithmic. Spotify builds it for each listener from their taste profile and refreshes it weekly, and there is no form to submit to it. Editors play no part in choosing its songs. Your influence comes from listener behavior such as saves and repeat plays.
Can I pay to get on a Spotify editorial playlist?
No. Spotify states that artists cannot pay for placement on its official playlists, and it treats offers to sell placement as streaming manipulation. The legitimate route is the free pitch form in Spotify for Artists, which must be submitted at least seven days before release.
Which is better for an independent artist, editorial or algorithmic?
Editorial placements can be larger in a single moment, but algorithmic playlists are the larger long-term discovery channel, since Spotify reports a third of new artist discoveries happen in personalized sessions. Most artists do best by pitching editors for free and building listener signals that feed the algorithms.
What is an algotorial playlist?
It is a playlist where Spotify's editors pick a pool of songs and algorithms personalize which tracks each listener sees and in what order. Many popular playlists work this way. It means a good editorial fit and good listener behavior both help.
How long does a song stay on Release Radar?
A song stays eligible for up to four weeks after release, and each listener sees one song per artist per week. Pitching at least seven days before release lets you choose which song is featured.

Ready for Real Playlists?

Playlist Pilot matches your song with real, active playlists across Spotify, checks them for bots and writes a personal pitch to each curator.